Game 1: Mrs. Carolyn Smallwood - ""Tax Collector"" (she is the Deputy Collector of Tax for her hometown of Rutherford, NJ; she collects real estate property taxes and business taxes) Game 2: Richard T. Armstrong - ""Clam Digger"" (he has been digging clams for 5 summers as he saves money for college; he collects 3 to 4 bushels daily, and said it is hard work; he is a pre-med student at Stoneybrook University on Long Island; from Huntington, Long Island, NY) Game 3: Shelley Winters (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Mrs. Shelagh Sloan - ""Professional Stilt Walker (Circus Act)"" (from London, England; she is the only female stilt walker with the Ringling Brothers Circus; her name is pronounced as Sheila, although spelled Shelagh; John said that in 1962, her husband was a contestant, but John did not mention his name; on EPISODE #644 on December 23, 1962, Barrie Sloan was indeed a contestant, then working for the Clyde Beatty Cole Bros Circus; pictures of the famous stilt-walking Sloan family ca (thetvdb.com)