Game 1: Alan Jay Lerner (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel was blindfolded) ""Author & Lyricist, My Fair Lady, Gigi, Camelot, On a Clear Day You Can See Forever"" (He said he is thinking about writing a work on the life of clothing designer Coco Chanel; see more notes below) Game 2: Mrs. Doris Mahelick - ""Police Commissioner"" (of Bergen County, New Jersey; from Wallington, NJ; she has 141 officers under her guidance) Game 3: Buddy Hackett (as Mystery Guest) He signed in as ""Newton Fig"" Game 4: Herbert Mayers - ""Mink Auctioneer"" (for Hudson's Bay Company, where he has been employed for 27 years; from New Hyde Park, NY) (thetvdb.com)