Game 1: Johnny Olson (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel was blindfolded) - ""Announcer for What's My Line?"" (Excellent game! Johnny Olson has so much personality!) See Randy West's tribute page here: Johnny Olson Tribute Game 2: Mr. Morrill A. Mace - ""Publishes New York City Telephone Book"" (from Darien, CT, he is the Assistant Vice-President of the New York Telephone Company; he publishes 156 telephone directories for the state of New York) Game 3: Maurice Chevalier (as Mystery Guest #2) Game 4: Miss Jean Murphy - ""Manages Pool Room"" (at ""Valley Cue"" billiards and pool room in her hometown of Emerson, NJ) (thetvdb.com)