Game 1: Frank Gifford (he signed in as F. Newton Gifford and the panel was not blindfolded) - ""Halfback on N. Y. Giants Football Team"" (salaried; he was involved in 4 touchdowns today; John said he was named All-American with USC in 1952; from Bakersfield, California) Game 2: Mrs. Maxine Rosen - ""Sells Mistletoe"" (salaried; from Detroit, Michigan) Game 3: Milton Berle (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Mrs. Florence H. Poole - ""Dog Catcher"" (salaried; from Chatham, Ontario, Canada) (thetvdb.com)