Game 1: Mr. C. C. Robertson (Charlie Robertson) - ""Nut Broker (Buys and Sells Pecans)"" (self-employed; he is a former major league baseball pitcher who pitched a perfect game in the 1920s; Bennett guesses his line) Game 2: Miss Ann Tidwell - ""Deals Cards In Gambling Casino (Reno, Nevada)"" (salaried; she works at the Mapes Hotel and Resort Casino; her home town is not revealed until after the game; from Reno, NV; Arlene guesses her line) Game 3: Jo Stafford (as Mystery Guest) Bennett Cerf identified her at $10. Game 4: Barbara Hammer - ""TV Comedy Writer (Has Written For Danny Thomas, Ray Bolger, Buddy Hackett, Etc.)"" (she won the full $50; she wrote several ""Mr. Magoo"" cartoon character stories from 1954 to 1955 as listed on IMDB) (thetvdb.com)